Join the Network!  
ProgressNow Colorado
RE: Mukasey doesn't know the techniques of torture
Bad? Brilliant?
You can rate this post.
Register or login now and
tell us what you think.

Why is the Attorney General worth the time to fight for?  Abu "no express habeas corpus in the Constitution" Gonzales.

Jeralyn, TalkLeft.com, writes:

Many people think the role of Attorney General is simply to be the nation's "top cop," the chief criminal law enforcer. But it is much more. The role of the Attorney General is to serve as America's lawyer, in civil as well as criminal matters. He is not the President's lawyer. He is our lawyer.

The White House has its own legal counsel which is called "The Office of Counsel to the President".  From Wikipedia.org:

The Office of Counsel to the President was created in 1943, and is responsible for advising on all legal aspects of policy questions, legal issues arising in connection with the President's decision to sign or veto legislation, ethical questions, financial disclosures, and conflicts of interest during employment and post employment. The Counsel's Office also helps define the line between official and political activities, oversees executive appointments and judicial selection, handles Presidential pardons, reviews legislation and Presidential statements, and handles lawsuits against the President in his role as President, as well as serving as the White House contact for the Department of Justice.

This is why the Department of Justice is critical to having our system of jurisprudience be unbiased and apolitical. 

The attorney general nominee Judge Mukasey on torture has told the Senate Judiciary Committee that he is against, but he now states:

At one point during the hearings, he told Sen. Durbin: "It is not constitutional for the United States to engage in torture in any form, be it waterboarding or anything else." In other words, waterboarding is torture when it rises to the level of torture (however torture might be defined) -- but the technique in and of itself does not necessarily constitute torture.

The ABA reports that even Senator Spector is troubled

I believe that if the American people really knew what waterboarding entailed (shown actual prisoners being waterboarded and not a reporter, Steve Harrigan, from Foxnews  calling it "not so bad") and that people were waterboarded in our system of interrogation camps for the Jack Bauer cold blooded murderer scenario- "Ticking Time Bomb" then there would be a great revulsion to Mr. Bush's policy of using torture techniques.

So, Judge Mukasey doesn't know the technique involved?  It is not necessary to know that because in his role as Attorney General he would be acting as an advisor to Mr. Bush, David Lubin writes:

However, Gonzales, Bybee, and their crew crossed a different ethical line. They were not acting as courtroom advocates but as legal advisers, with a different professional standard to which they needed to adhere. Model Rule 2.1, titled "Advisor," provides that "a lawyer shall exercise independent professional judgment and render candid advice." Legal advisers must play it straight, even where the "[l]egal advice [may] involve[] unpleasant facts and alternatives that a client may be disinclined to confront." Independence means saying what the law is—as mainstream lawyers and judges understand it—regardless of what the client wishes it to be. Candor requires lawyers with eccentric theories to warn their clients whenever their legal advice veers away from the mainstream. The torture lawyers betrayed both these principles with the advice they gave the White House.

As the Attorney General he would have broad sway of policy implementation and discretion at to what policies to enforce.

David Lubin continues:

But what happens when the client doesn't want candid advice? When the client says, in effect, "Give me a legal opinion saying I can do what I want to do"? Lawyers confront such requests every day—but if the lawyer does the client's bidding, she has crossed the fatal line from adviser to accomplice.

What cannot be clearer is that Judge Mukasey is against torture before he is for torture.

Why should Democrats vote to approve out of committee Judge Mukasey to the full Senate?  The New York Times reporter Philip Shenon writes:

Many Democratic lawmakers say privately that he is still likely to be confirmed, given the need for leadership in the Justice Department after months of turmoil.

What kind of reason is that?  This is capitulation to Mr. Bush who continues to send up unqualified people for administration posts.

Let our Senator Salazar know that we will support a primary challenge to him if he doesn't uphold his oath to the Constitution and Bill of Rights. 


Reader Comments

Comments are closed for this post.

No comments have been written yet.
Highest Rated All Network Posts

Saturday Mailbag: ACES Edition

Posted Jul 04, 2009 1:27pm
Comments (0)

Why we never need to build another polluting power plant

Posted Jul 03, 2009 9:24am
Comments (0)

Sarah Palin's Toxic Paradise

Posted Jul 03, 2009 9:08am
Comments (0)

Who Lincoln Was

Posted Jul 03, 2009 8:34am
Comments (0)

When Our Brains Short-Circuit

Posted Jul 02, 2009 5:58pm
Comments (0)

Memo To Deficit Hawks: Public Plan Option Indisputably Saves Money

Posted Jul 02, 2009 11:54am
Comments (0)

Al Franken Quote

Posted Jul 02, 2009 11:07am
Comments (0)

The Patients Doctors Don’t Know

Posted Jul 02, 2009 8:13am
Comments (0)

Facebook is the Source of Depressing News

Posted Jul 02, 2009 6:32am
Comments (1)

Adult harassment of transchild by proxy-

Posted Jul 02, 2009 3:49am
Comments (0)

* NOTE: ProgressNow Colorado is not responsible for the content of member postings.



Search Blog

Make a Donation
Find People
Find Groups
Find Events
Write Officials
Join our group on FacebookFollow us on TwitterProgressive JobwireProgressNow State Partner Colorado Blogs

National Blogs

1536 Wynkoop St., #4A, Denver, CO 80202 | ph: (303) 991-1900 | fax: (303) 991-1902 | progress@progressnowcolorado.org

© 2005-2009 ProgressNow Colorado, All rights reserved. Privacy Policy. Fair Use Statement. Terms of Service.